The incense burner is one of the few objects in a columbarium that is used every day and rarely chosen with any care Choose wrong and it will not fail immediately, but two years later three things appear: the body becomes too hot to touch, the rim cracks, and the sticks will not stand straight. None of these is a user problem. All three are material problems.

Copper. The most common in front of a niche. It conducts heat quickly, withstands heat well and does not crack. The drawback is heat: the wall can exceed 80 °C, and a visitor's knuckles brush it when inserting a stick.
Ceramic. The cheapest in a niche, and the best looking, with many colours. The drawback is brittleness — thermal cycling crazes the glaze, and a drop shatters it.
Stone. Steady, heat-resistant, indifferent to knocks. The drawbacks are weight — a 30 cm stone burner weighs over ten kilos and cannot be lifted for cleaning — and porosity, since ash works into the micropores and cannot be washed out.
Stainless steel. Durable, cheap, easy to clean. The drawback is that ash collects at the seams, and poorly finished welds rust.
What you see most often in a columbarium is a copper burner on a stone plinth, or a small-bore stainless burner.
Copper's thermal conductivity is about 400 W/(m·K), several hundred times that of ceramic. This means the wall quickly approaches the internal temperature and a fingertip on the rim is a burn.
There are two fixes.
Thicken the wall. On a small burner before a niche, going from 2 mm to 3–4 mm slows conduction and can drop the outer wall temperature by 15–20 °C. The price is double the weight.
Add an insulating seat. Sit the burner on a timber or stone base so its underside does not touch the niche ledge directly. This matters especially for small burners before a niche: if the ledge has a timber lining, prolonged heat will discolour it.
Copper's other advantage is weathering. The surface forms an oxide layer naturally, turning from bright yellow to dark brown, gaining gravity with use. That "old but not dirty" quality in a columbarium usually comes from copper.
Ceramic's fatal problem is thermal shock. The interior goes from ambient to several hundred degrees, the temperature difference across the wall is large, and glaze and body have different expansion coefficients; a few cycles and it crazes.
Crazing alone does not stop it working, but cleaning in a columbarium is a wet wipe — water enters the cracks, and on the next heating the moisture expands and the crack grows. In about two years a hairline becomes a chip.
If you must use ceramic in a columbarium, choose a thick-bodied, unglazed-interior coarse pottery rather than thin-bodied bone china. Coarse pottery is far more resistant to thermal shock.
Stone's advantages are concrete: a low centre of gravity, indifferent to knocks and heat, and visually it holds a space down.
The problems are weight and staining. A 25 cm square granite burner weighs 15–20 kg and needs two people to lift for cleaning. And the micropores absorb incense ash and fragrance oils; over time the body goes black and no brush brings it back.
Stone suits a fixed communal burner area. It does not suit a small burner before a niche.

Stainless is used more and more in columbaria because it fears neither water nor knocks and costs little.
Judge it on one thing: the weld. A good burner is pressed in one piece or seamlessly welded, with a smooth interior. A poor one is two pieces joined, leaving a raised seam where ash packs in, builds up and eventually turns black and sour.
Also check the gauge. Below 0.8 mm, the side wall bulges once filled with ash; 1.2 mm and above is stable.
Small burner before a niche: 12–15 cm mouth, 10–12 cm high. This size holds three sticks, occupies little space, and does not obstruct the door.
Communal burner in a hall: 30–40 cm mouth, 25–30 cm high, on a stone or concrete plinth.
Ash depth: whichever type, the ash bed must be at least 5 cm deep for sticks to stand. A new burner must be filled first (ash, or rice, or sand); never insert a stick into an empty burner.
This is the most commonly overlooked point in a columbarium. Insert into an empty burner and the stick always leans, and the ash will not hold it.
Look at three things.
1. Is there an insulating ring or a thickened rim at the mouth? 2. Is there a stone or metal plinth below, and does it show scorch marks? 3. Is the ash level and free of clumps?
The third says most about management Ash has to be sieved and levelled daily; clumped ash means nobody has tended it for a long time. The detail in a columbarium lives in exactly these objects that are touched every day.
Q: Must there be a burner in front of a niche?
A: In a smoke-free hall, most do not place a live-flame burner; they use an electronic one or simply a vase. If a burner is placed, it is decorative and not lit.
Q: What if the copper burner has rusted?
A: What looks like rust on copper is usually verdigris. Wipe with a soft cloth and a little white vinegar, then dry immediately. Do not use steel wool; it leaves scratches.
Q: The ceramic burner has a crack. Can it still be used?
A: An indoor small burner can continue in use, but do not put hot water in it and do not soak it for cleaning. Ash collects in the crack and eventually smells.

The material depends on where the burner sits: stone or thick copper in a communal area, thickened copper or 1.2 mm stainless before a niche. Ceramic looks good but fears thermal shock; stone is steady but cannot be lifted. What a columbarium most often neglects is that 5 cm ash bed — however good the burner, a stick that will not stand is useless.