These family meetings are becoming more frequent: the younger generation argues for tree burial or flower burial — it takes no land, it returns to nature; the elders insist on a columbarium niche, saying "there has to be somewhere we can go and see them."

Both sides are reasonable, which is why they cannot agree. This is not a debate about environmental values. It is two needs colliding — one wants to leave no trace, the other wants to leave a coordinate. Separate those two and the choice becomes easy.
The core of tree burial, flower burial and woodland interment is: no stele, no grave mound, cremated remains processed further and buried in the soil. In many places the practice is to reuse the same grove, turning the soil and resetting it after a few years.
That implies three things: there is no fixed position you can point to; you cannot lay offerings or burn incense; you cannot stand at the same spot once a year.
Sea burial is more absolute still: the ashes are scattered in a designated area, the ceremony happens on the boat, and afterwards there is no place to return to.
For people who believe in the environmental case, these are advantages. For people who need to go and see, they are a gap. And that gap is exactly what a columbarium niche exists to fill.
The first is a coordinate. Hall column, tier, number — an address you can recite. People need this, especially in the first two years.
The second is a container. Ashes need a physically protected place: stable humidity, protection from light, a door, a lock. The carcass, door panel and lock of a niche do exactly this.
The third is ritual space. Paying respects needs somewhere you can stand, kneel, lay out offerings and speak. The aisles, offering tables and incense burners of a columbarium hall exist for that.
Eco-burial gives up mainly the first and the third. So the real question is not "should we be green". It is "does this family still need a point to return to".
The first is division. Part of the ashes goes into a niche, part is scattered. Many families accept this by default: it settles the debt to nature and keeps a niche that can be visited. One practical point — decide on division before the ashes are sealed into the urn. Taking them out again afterwards is a much heavier psychological burden for a family.
The second is downsizing. A small-format niche, holding one urn, with no display of keepsakes. It occupies less, but the coordinate survives. Demand for small-format niches has risen in recent years, and the reason is not cost saving. It is "I only need a position, not a room".
The third is the family niche. One full cavity per family, several generations together. In land-scarce places this is actually the greener option — land per person is far lower than a single niche, and far lower than a family plot.

If a columbarium's clientele arrives as two generations together, the design must leave physical room for compromise.
First, double and family niches must make up a proportion. If a columbarium design is all single niches, the family is forced to choose between buying two or buying one, when what they actually need is "buy one now, add later".
Second, reserve a memorial wall. No niche, no ashes, just names engraved. Families who choose eco-burial often need exactly such a wall — it gives them a place to point to without consuming land. A memorial wall costs very little inside a columbarium and carries enormous emotional value. It is the best value-for-money item in the entire building.
Third, online memorial services need a physical anchor. QR codes and online memorial halls are useless if they exist only on a phone, because the elders will not use them. Make it a small plaque on the memorial wall, and people will actually scan it.
My advice: do not argue values. Argue routes.
"After a tree burial, where do we go to see you?" Ask that question and most elders fall silent — not because they oppose environmental burial, but because they cannot name an address.
Conversely, if the proposal is "part in a niche, part scattered at sea", the elders will usually relent, because they get the coordinate and the young get their answer to nature. In that arrangement the niche is not a product of compromise. It is the fulcrum of the compromise.
Q: Can an eco-burial later be converted to a niche?
Usually not. Tree, flower and sea burial do not retain recoverable ashes — that is their premise. So this decision is irreversible, and the whole family must agree before it is made.
Q: Is a niche therefore not environmentally sound?
It depends how you count. A niche occupies under 0.15 m², stacked vertically, so land consumption per person is far below a traditional grave. The genuine environmental issues are stone consumption and energy use, and both can be optimised in columbarium design.
Q: The family already bought a niche, but the elder wants scattering. What now?
First establish whether the contract allows variation or transfer, then talk about feelings. A right of use can generally be transferred, and transferring to another family in the same park is not difficult. The loss is smaller than you would imagine.

Eco-burial and the columbarium niche are not a choice between advanced and backward. They are a choice between leaving nothing and leaving a coordinate. Whether a family can reach agreement depends on whether someone is willing to say both of those things out loud. And what a columbarium can do is build the compromise path properly: a smaller niche, a cavity that can be extended, a wall that can carry a name.